agent

+19:23
reasoning

Initial focus is on the atelier_board.py script and its build() function, which constructs a rigged mech. The frame_std skeleton is key, particularly its build functions and proportions. Examining frame_std.py lines 301-435 should reveal these details.

  • read_file{"EndLine":435,"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/frame_std.py","StartLine":301}

    input

    {
      "EndLine": 435,
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/frame_std.py",
      "StartLine": 301
    }

    result, 136 lines

    Showing lines 301-435 of 435
    301:     pad("backpack", B, *BACK_PAD)
    302:     for s, sx in (("L", 1), ("R", -1)):
    303:         x0, x1 = sorted((.48 * sx, .72 * sx))
    304:         solid(f"binder_arm.{s}", box(x0, x1, 1.3, 2.25, 14.58, 14.82), "frame", B, bevel=.02)
    305:         solid(f"binder_hinge.{s}", cylinder(.2, .9 * sx - .24, .9 * sx + .24, 12, axis="x", at=(2.25, 14.7)), "joint", J["binder", s],
    306:               smooth=True)
    307: 
    308: 
    309: KNEE_FORWARD = .42  # how far the knees stand forward of the hip to ankle line
    310: SPLAY = .4  # how far each foot stands out from under its hip: a slight A stance
    311: 
    312: 
    313: def bend_knees(J, forward=KNEE_FORWARD, splay=SPLAY):
    314:     """Stand the frame with its knees a little forward and its feet a little apart, so the leg is
    315:     not one straight post. Run after the plates are on. Everything under a thigh or shin moves along
    316:     y by an offset that runs from 0 at the hip to -forward at the knee and back to 0 at the ankle,
    317:     and outward by one that runs from 0 at the hip to `splay` at the ankle. The foot moves out whole.
    318:     Joints move with their parts. Joint names and the tree stay as they are."""
    319:     for s, sx in (("L", 1), ("R", -1)):
    320:         hip, knee, foot = J["thigh", s], J["shin", s], J["foot", s]
    321:         zh, zk, za = hip.matrix_world.translation.z, knee.matrix_world.translation.z, foot.matrix_world.translation.z
    322: 
    323:         def d(z):
    324:             out = sx * splay * (1.0 if z <= za else 0.0 if z >= zh else (zh - z) / (zh - za))
    325:             if z >= zh or z <= za:
    326:                 return Vector((out, 0, 0))
    327:             return Vector((out, -forward * ((zh - z) / (zh - zk) if z >= zk else (z - za) / (zk - za)), 0))
    328: 
    329:         order, stack = [], [hip]
    330:         while stack:
    331:             o = stack.pop(0)
    332:             order.append(o)
    333:             stack.extend(o.children)
    334:         keep = {foot} | set(foot.children_recursive)
    335:         world = {o: o.matrix_world.copy() for o in order}
    336:         for o in order:
    337:             if o in keep:
    338:                 world[o] = Matrix.Translation(d(za - 1)) @ world[o]
    339:                 continue
    340:             if o.type == "MESH":
    341:                 inv = world[o].inverted()
    342:                 for v in o.data.vertices:
    343:                     w = world[o] @ v.co
    344:                     v.co = inv @ (w + d(w.z))
    345:             else:
    346:                 world[o] = Matrix.Translation(d(world[o].translation.z)) @ world[o]
    347:         for o in order:
    348:             o.matrix_world = world[o]
    349:             bpy.context.view_layer.update()
    350: 
    351: 
    352: # The pattern builds' proportions, as fractions of the crown height (docs/study-proportions.md): the
    353: # knee joint, the crotch, and the crown itself in metres. The antenna stands above the crown.
    354: KNEE_AT = .39
    355: CROTCH_AT = .54
    356: CROWN = 16.9
    357: CROTCH_Z = 9.74  # the crotch's height on the striker rig, before proportion
    358: SHOULDER_OUT = .25  # how far the shoulders move out, the chest top widening to meet them
    359: KNEE_BAND = .55  # half height of the knee region that moves whole, so the knee block keeps its shape
    360: SHIN_FROM = 2.0  # the ankle and foot below this height stay as they are
    361: THIGH_TO = 9.55  # the hip and everything above it move whole
    362: 
    363: 
    364: def proportion(J, crown_z, knee=KNEE_AT, crotch=CROTCH_AT, crown=CROWN, shoulders=SHOULDER_OUT):
    365:     """Set the build's proportions on world positions, after the plates and bend_knees. `crown_z` is the
    366:     helmet top before this pass. The thigh is shortened and the body comes down onto it so the crotch
    367:     sits at `crotch` of the crown and the knee at `knee`: a long shin under a short thigh, the line
    368:     mech's leg. The knee region moves whole, the shin and thigh stretch or squeeze between it and the
    369:     ankle and hip. Everything not under a thigh moves down whole. The shoulders move out by
    370:     `shoulders`, the chest top widening with them. Then the whole frame is scaled so the crown lands at
    371:     `crown`. Joint names and the tree stay as they are."""
    372:     zk = J["shin", "L"].matrix_world.translation.z
    373:     d = (crotch * crown_z - CROTCH_Z) / (1 - crotch)  # the body's drop
    374:     zk2 = knee * (crown_z + d)
    375:     k = crown / (crown_z + d)
    376:     b = KNEE_BAND
    377: 
    378:     def lerp(z, a0, a1, b0, b1):
    379:         return b0 + (z - a0) * (b1 - b0) / (a1 - a0)
    380: 
    381:     def leg(z):
    382:         if z <= SHIN_FROM:
    383:             return z
    384:         if z <= zk - b:
    385:             return lerp(z, SHIN_FROM, zk - b, SHIN_FROM, zk2 - b)
    386:         if z <= zk + b:
    387:             return z + zk2 - zk
    388:         if z <= THIGH_TO:
    389:             return lerp(z, zk + b, THIGH_TO, zk2 + b, THIGH_TO + d)
    390:         return z + d
    391: 
    392:     def wide(x):
    393:         """The shoulders' move out at |x|: none inside the chest, whole past the shoulder joint."""
    394:         t = min(max((abs(x) - 1.25) / (2.05 - 1.25), 0.0), 1.0)
    395:         return math.copysign(shoulders * t * t * (3 - 2 * t), x)
    396: 
    397:     root = J["frame"]
    398:     legs = set()
    399:     for s in ("L", "R"):
    400:         legs |= {J["thigh", s]} | set(J["thigh", s].children_recursive)
    401:     upper = set(J["torso"].children_recursive) - ({J["neck"]} | set(J["neck"].children_recursive))
    402: 
    403:     def m(o, p):
    404:         z = leg(p.z) if o in legs else p.z + d
    405:         x = p.x + wide(p.x) if o in upper or o is J["torso"] else p.x
    406:         return Vector((x * k, p.y * k, z * k))
    407: 
    408:     order, stack = [], [root]
    409:     while stack:
    410:         o = stack.pop(0)
    411:         order.append(o)
    412:         stack.extend(o.children)
    413:     world = {o: o.matrix_world.copy() for o in order}
    414:     for o in order:
    415:         if o.type == "MESH":
    416:             inv = world[o].inverted()
    417:             for v in o.data.vertices:
    418:                 v.co = inv @ m(o, world[o] @ v.co)
    419:         elif o is not root:
    420:             world[o] = Matrix.Translation(m(o, world[o].translation) - world[o].translation) @ world[o]
    421:     for o in order:
    422:         o.matrix_world = world[o]
    423:         bpy.context.view_layer.update()
    424: 
    425: 
    426: def build_frame(tag="frame_std"):
    427:     J = joints(tag)
    428:     build_pelvis(J)
    429:     build_waist(J)
    430:     build_torso(J)
    431:     build_head(J)
    432:     build_arms(J)
    433:     build_legs(J)
    434:     build_backpack(J)
    435:     return J

agent

+19:36
reasoning

The initial assumption was that the issue resided elsewhere, but the focus shifted to kit/frame_std.py. Examining the proportion() function within revealed discrepancies in crown_z values. This suggests a potential miscalculation or incorrect variable assignment related to these crucial parameters.

The analysis now focuses on the implications of the calculated body drop (d) and its effect on the leg positioning. Specifically, the knee position is recalculated, revealing an upward shift. This leg positioning logic introduces a potential discrepancy when meshes attached to the pelvis are not explicitly part of the "legs" definition, as this discrepancy leads to incorrect calculations. This suggests that the inclusion logic for meshes, particularly those linked to the pelvis but not part of the leg structure, needs careful examination.

The leg positioning discrepancy is exacerbated by interactions with the cover_fauld_front operation. This placement leads to overlapping geometries which produce artifacts. Further investigation is needed to see if the interaction of these operations introduces issues when combined with other joint manipulations. The discrepancy in joint positions highlights a need to carefully review the mesh assignment strategy, specifically regarding meshes attached to the pelvis.

The placement of the cover_fauld_front is causing the painted crotch armor to be obscured on every knight model. This is due to an offset where the cover_fauld_front is positioned further forward than the crotch plate. Similarly, the cover_armpit placement results in prominent black washboards on the chest due to its forward positioning relative to the chest's outer edge. This suggests a need to adjust the positioning parameters for these elements to prevent overlapping and ensure proper visual representation. Attempting modifications to the relevant scripts.

Examining the script updates, it's clear the changes aim to improve normal calculation and edge handling. Specifically, splitting edges with angles greater than 12 degrees is implemented to achieve sharper visual transitions in the model. Defaulting the bevel parameter to zero in the put() and put2() functions prevents unwanted bevel operations, ensuring that the splitting of the edges is preserved. The logic for splitting edges is being added after the boolean subtraction operations, and a helper to ensure smooth visual transitions.

The current hypothesis is that adjusting the edge angle threshold and modifying specific positional parameters will resolve the visual artifacts. Specifically, the angle threshold for edge splitting is being reduced, along with parameter adjustments for joint covers. These changes are intended to address issues with overlapping geometries and incorrect scaling in the model. Additionally, adjustments to the leg scaling are being considered to correct the proportions of the foot.

  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py","Replacement":" bmesh.ops.remove_doubles(bm, verts=bm.verts, dist=1e-6) # closes a pole\n bmesh.ops.recalc_face_normals(bm, faces=bm.faces)\n sharp = [e for e in bm.edges if len(e.link_faces) == 2 and e.link_faces[0].normal.angle(e.link_faces[1].normal, 0) > math.radians(12)]\n if sharp:\n bmesh.ops.split_edges(bm, edges=sharp)\n return bm","Target":" bmesh.ops.remove_doubles(bm, verts=bm.verts, dist=1e-6) # closes a pole\n bmesh.ops.recalc_face_normals(bm, faces=bm.faces)\n return bm"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py",
      "Replacement": "        bmesh.ops.remove_doubles(bm, verts=bm.verts, dist=1e-6)  # closes a pole\n        bmesh.ops.recalc_face_normals(bm, faces=bm.faces)\n        sharp = [e for e in bm.edges if len(e.link_faces) == 2 and e.link_faces[0].normal.angle(e.link_faces[1].normal, 0) > math.radians(12)]\n        if sharp:\n            bmesh.ops.split_edges(bm, edges=sharp)\n        return bm",
      "Target": "        bmesh.ops.remove_doubles(bm, verts=bm.verts, dist=1e-6)  # closes a pole\n        bmesh.ops.recalc_face_normals(bm, faces=bm.faces)\n        return bm"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py starting at line 94 (+3/-0 lines).
  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py","Replacement":"def put(P, name, sheet, role, jl, jr=None, bevel=0):\n \"\"\"A sheet as a plate on a joint (mirrored onto jr).\"\"\"\n P.solid(name, sheet.bm(), role, jl, jr, bevel=bevel)","Target":"def put(P, name, sheet, role, jl, jr=None, bevel=.012):\n \"\"\"A sheet as a plate on a joint (mirrored onto jr).\"\"\"\n P.solid(name, sheet.bm(), role, jl, jr, bevel=bevel)"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py",
      "Replacement": "def put(P, name, sheet, role, jl, jr=None, bevel=0):\n    \"\"\"A sheet as a plate on a joint (mirrored onto jr).\"\"\"\n    P.solid(name, sheet.bm(), role, jl, jr, bevel=bevel)",
      "Target": "def put(P, name, sheet, role, jl, jr=None, bevel=.012):\n    \"\"\"A sheet as a plate on a joint (mirrored onto jr).\"\"\"\n    P.solid(name, sheet.bm(), role, jl, jr, bevel=bevel)"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py starting at line 231 (+1/-1 lines).
  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py","Replacement":"def put2(P, name, bm, jl, jr, roles, bevel=0):\n \"\"\"A plate on jl, mirrored onto jr, each side its own role: roles is one role or (left, right).\"\"\"","Target":"def put2(P, name, bm, jl, jr, roles, bevel=.012):\n \"\"\"A plate on jl, mirrored onto jr, each side its own role: roles is one role or (left, right).\"\"\""}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py",
      "Replacement": "def put2(P, name, bm, jl, jr, roles, bevel=0):\n    \"\"\"A plate on jl, mirrored onto jr, each side its own role: roles is one role or (left, right).\"\"\"",
      "Target": "def put2(P, name, bm, jl, jr, roles, bevel=.012):\n    \"\"\"A plate on jl, mirrored onto jr, each side its own role: roles is one role or (left, right).\"\"\""
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py starting at line 381 (+1/-1 lines).
  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py","Replacement":" fz = by(g, 9.85, 9.4, 9.0)\n secs = [(\"back\", lin(55, 125, 12))]\n for nm, us in secs:\n cover(P, f\"cover_fauld_{nm}\", (0, .05), fz, 10.95, [1.22, 1.18, 1.14], us, J[\"pelvis\"], style=fauld, rows=by(g, 3, 4, 5), kx=1.02, ky=.9,\n amp=.35)\n if g != \"light\":\n cover(P, \"cover_fauld_side\", (0, .05), fz + .35, 10.85, [1.14, 1.12, 1.08], lin(-26, 26, 10), J[\"pelvis\"], J[\"pelvis\"], style=fauld,\n rows=by(g, 3, 4, 5), kx=1.0, ky=.88, amp=.3)\n # the thigh under the cuisse, front and back plates or not\n # the thigh under the cuisse: a quiet quilt whatever the line, it is a gap between plates, not a joint\n cover(P, \"cover_thigh\", (1.16, 0), 6.9, 9.75, [.7, .72, .72], RING, *TH, style=\"quilt\", rows=3, wrap=True, amp=.5, cols=45)\n # knee: a pad behind (light), a ring round it (heavy)\n kus = by(g, lin(40, 140, 12), lin(30, 150, 14), lin(15, 165, 18)) # behind only: the front is the poleyn's\n # flat behind, shallow folds only in the bend\n cover(P, \"cover_knee\", (1.2, .05), 5.4, 6.9, [.9, .92, .92, .9], kus, *SH, style=style, rows=3, amp=.4)\n # the hip: a roll round the top of each thigh under the fauld\n cover(P, \"cover_hip\", (1.16, .02), 9.55, 10.75, [.86, .9, .84], RING, *TH, style=style, rows=2, wrap=True)\n # the shoulder socket: a roll round the frame's shoulder bar from the chest side to the pauldron, so the\n # bar's square ends do not show\n cover_x(P, \"cover_socket\", (0, 14.62), 1.22, 2.2, [.46, .5, .58, .66], *S, style=style, rows=3, amp=.5)\n # the armpit gusset, tucked between the chest side and the arm over the shoulder rams\n cover(P, \"cover_armpit\", (1.92, .08), 13.0, 14.35, [.44, .48, .52], lin(160, 225, 12), *S, style=style, rows=4, amp=.4)","Target":" fz = by(g, 9.85, 9.4, 9.0)\n secs = [(\"back\", lin(55, 125, 12))] + ([] if g == \"light\" else [(\"front\", lin(-118, -62, 10))])\n for nm, us in secs:\n cover(P, f\"cover_fauld_{nm}\", (0, .05), fz, 10.95, [1.32, 1.28, 1.24], us, J[\"pelvis\"], style=fauld, rows=by(g, 3, 4, 5), kx=1.05, ky=.9,\n amp=.35)\n if g != \"light\":\n cover(P, \"cover_fauld_side\", (0, .05), fz + .2, 10.9, [1.42, 1.38, 1.32], lin(-30, 30, 10), J[\"pelvis\"], J[\"pelvis\"], style=fauld,\n rows=by(g, 3, 4, 5), kx=1.05, ky=.9, amp=.35)\n # the thigh under the cuisse, front and back plates or not\n # the thigh under the cuisse: a quiet quilt whatever the line, it is a gap between plates, not a joint\n cover(P, \"cover_thigh\", (1.16, 0), 6.9, 9.75, [.7, .72, .72], RING, *TH, style=\"quilt\", rows=3, wrap=True, amp=.5, cols=45)\n # knee: a pad behind (light), a ring round it (heavy)\n kus = by(g, lin(40, 140, 12), lin(30, 150, 14), lin(15, 165, 18)) # behind only: the front is the poleyn's\n # flat behind, shallow folds only in the bend\n cover(P, \"cover_knee\", (1.2, .05), 5.4, 6.9, [.9, .92, .92, .9], kus, *SH, style=style, rows=3, amp=.4)\n # the hip: a roll round the top of each thigh under the fauld\n cover(P, \"cover_hip\", (1.16, .02), 9.55, 10.75, [.86, .9, .84], RING, *TH, style=style, rows=2, wrap=True)\n # the shoulder socket: a roll round the frame's shoulder bar from the chest side to the pauldron, so the\n # bar's square ends do not show\n cover_x(P, \"cover_socket\", (0, 14.62), 1.22, 2.2, [.46, .5, .58, .66], *S, style=style, rows=3, amp=.5)\n # the armpit gusset, between the chest side and the arm, over the rams at the chest corners\n cover(P, \"cover_armpit\", (2.45, 0), 12.7, 14.4, [1.0, 1.12, 1.18], lin(140, 262, 18), *S, style=style, rows=4)"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py",
      "Replacement": "    fz = by(g, 9.85, 9.4, 9.0)\n    secs = [(\"back\", lin(55, 125, 12))]\n    for nm, us in secs:\n        cover(P, f\"cover_fauld_{nm}\", (0, .05), fz, 10.95, [1.22, 1.18, 1.14], us, J[\"pelvis\"], style=fauld, rows=by(g, 3, 4, 5), kx=1.02, ky=.9,\n              amp=.35)\n    if g != \"light\":\n        cover(P, \"cover_fauld_side\", (0, .05), fz + .35, 10.85, [1.14, 1.12, 1.08], lin(-26, 26, 10), J[\"pelvis\"], J[\"pelvis\"], style=fauld,\n              rows=by(g, 3, 4, 5), kx=1.0, ky=.88, amp=.3)\n    # the thigh under the cuisse, front and back plates or not\n    # the thigh under the cuisse: a quiet quilt whatever the line, it is a gap between plates, not a joint\n    cover(P, \"cover_thigh\", (1.16, 0), 6.9, 9.75, [.7, .72, .72], RING, *TH, style=\"quilt\", rows=3, wrap=True, amp=.5, cols=45)\n    # knee: a pad behind (light), a ring round it (heavy)\n    kus = by(g, lin(40, 140, 12), lin(30, 150, 14), lin(15, 165, 18))  # behind only: the front is the poleyn's\n    # flat behind, shallow folds only in the bend\n    cover(P, \"cover_knee\", (1.2, .05), 5.4, 6.9, [.9, .92, .92, .9], kus, *SH, style=style, rows=3, amp=.4)\n    # the hip: a roll round the top of each thigh under the fauld\n    cover(P, \"cover_hip\", (1.16, .02), 9.55, 10.75, [.86, .9, .84], RING, *TH, style=style, rows=2, wrap=True)\n    # the shoulder socket: a roll round the frame's shoulder bar from the chest side to the pauldron, so the\n    # bar's square ends do not show\n    cover_x(P, \"cover_socket\", (0, 14.62), 1.22, 2.2, [.46, .5, .58, .66], *S, style=style, rows=3, amp=.5)\n    # the armpit gusset, tucked between the chest side and the arm over the shoulder rams\n    cover(P, \"cover_armpit\", (1.92, .08), 13.0, 14.35, [.44, .48, .52], lin(160, 225, 12), *S, style=style, rows=4, amp=.4)",
      "Target": "    fz = by(g, 9.85, 9.4, 9.0)\n    secs = [(\"back\", lin(55, 125, 12))] + ([] if g == \"light\" else [(\"front\", lin(-118, -62, 10))])\n    for nm, us in secs:\n        cover(P, f\"cover_fauld_{nm}\", (0, .05), fz, 10.95, [1.32, 1.28, 1.24], us, J[\"pelvis\"], style=fauld, rows=by(g, 3, 4, 5), kx=1.05, ky=.9,\n              amp=.35)\n    if g != \"light\":\n        cover(P, \"cover_fauld_side\", (0, .05), fz + .2, 10.9, [1.42, 1.38, 1.32], lin(-30, 30, 10), J[\"pelvis\"], J[\"pelvis\"], style=fauld,\n              rows=by(g, 3, 4, 5), kx=1.05, ky=.9, amp=.35)\n    # the thigh under the cuisse, front and back plates or not\n    # the thigh under the cuisse: a quiet quilt whatever the line, it is a gap between plates, not a joint\n    cover(P, \"cover_thigh\", (1.16, 0), 6.9, 9.75, [.7, .72, .72], RING, *TH, style=\"quilt\", rows=3, wrap=True, amp=.5, cols=45)\n    # knee: a pad behind (light), a ring round it (heavy)\n    kus = by(g, lin(40, 140, 12), lin(30, 150, 14), lin(15, 165, 18))  # behind only: the front is the poleyn's\n    # flat behind, shallow folds only in the bend\n    cover(P, \"cover_knee\", (1.2, .05), 5.4, 6.9, [.9, .92, .92, .9], kus, *SH, style=style, rows=3, amp=.4)\n    # the hip: a roll round the top of each thigh under the fauld\n    cover(P, \"cover_hip\", (1.16, .02), 9.55, 10.75, [.86, .9, .84], RING, *TH, style=style, rows=2, wrap=True)\n    # the shoulder socket: a roll round the frame's shoulder bar from the chest side to the pauldron, so the\n    # bar's square ends do not show\n    cover_x(P, \"cover_socket\", (0, 14.62), 1.22, 2.2, [.46, .5, .58, .66], *S, style=style, rows=3, amp=.5)\n    # the armpit gusset, between the chest side and the arm, over the rams at the chest corners\n    cover(P, \"cover_armpit\", (2.45, 0), 12.7, 14.4, [1.0, 1.12, 1.18], lin(140, 262, 18), *S, style=style, rows=4)"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py starting at line 481 (+6/-6 lines).
  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/lib.py","Replacement":" me = o.data\n if smooth:\n me.shade_smooth()\n me.set_sharp_from_angle(angle=math.radians(15))","Target":" me = o.data\n if smooth:\n me.shade_smooth()\n me.set_sharp_from_angle(angle=math.radians(35))"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/lib.py",
      "Replacement": "    me = o.data\n    if smooth:\n        me.shade_smooth()\n        me.set_sharp_from_angle(angle=math.radians(15))",
      "Target": "    me = o.data\n    if smooth:\n        me.shade_smooth()\n        me.set_sharp_from_angle(angle=math.radians(35))"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/lib.py starting at line 198 (+1/-1 lines).
  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/frame_std.py","Replacement":"TURN = 6.0\nFOOT_SCALE = (1.06, 1.04) # across and along\nANKLE = (1.2, .1, 1.55)","Target":"TURN = 6.0\nFOOT_SCALE = (1.45, .82) # across and along\nANKLE = (1.2, .1, 1.55)"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/frame_std.py",
      "Replacement": "TURN = 6.0\nFOOT_SCALE = (1.06, 1.04)  # across and along\nANKLE = (1.2, .1, 1.55)",
      "Target": "TURN = 6.0\nFOOT_SCALE = (1.45, .82)  # across and along\nANKLE = (1.2, .1, 1.55)"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/frame_std.py starting at line 255 (+1/-1 lines).
  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/frame_std.py","Replacement":" # the rear foot: heel and arch on one sole, tapered to sit cleanly under pointed sabatons\n plan = [(.9, 1.12), (1.5, 1.12), (1.56, .82), (1.52, -1.48), (.88, -1.48), (.84, .82)]\n arch = [(-1.48, .28), (-1.48, 0), (-1.1, 0), (-.9, .14), (.3, .14), (.5, 0), (1.04, 0), (1.14, .14), (1.14, .28)]\n pair(\"sole\", place_foot(two_view([(.82, 0), (1.58, 0), (1.58, .28), (.82, .28)], arch, plan)), \"joint\", *FT, bevel=.02)\n pair(\"foot_frame\", place_foot(two_view([(.88, .27), (1.52, .27), (1.48, .58), (.92, .58)],\n [(-1.42, .27), (1.04, .27), (.94, .6), (-1.36, .46)])), \"frame\", *FT, bevel=BEVEL)\n pair(\"toe_hinge\", place_foot(cylinder(.12, .9, 1.5, 10, axis=\"x\", at=(-1.54, .24))), \"joint\", *FT, smooth=True)\n toe_plan = [(.88, -1.58), (1.52, -1.58), (1.44, -2.25), (1.3, -2.72), (1.1, -2.72), (.96, -2.25)]\n pair(\"toe_frame\", place_foot(two_view([(.86, .06), (1.54, .06), (1.54, .38), (.86, .38)],\n [(-1.58, .06), (-2.65, .06), (-2.72, .14), (-2.55, .26), (-1.58, .38)], toe_plan)), \"frame\", *FT,\n bevel=BEVEL)\n pair(\"toe_sole\", place_foot(two_view([(.86, 0), (1.54, 0), (1.54, .07), (.86, .07)], [(-1.58, 0), (-2.65, 0), (-2.65, .07), (-1.58, .07)],\n toe_plan)), \"joint\", *FT, bevel=.015)\n pair(\"heel_frame\", place_foot(box(.9, 1.5, .56, 1.08, .26, .58)), \"frame\", *FT, bevel=.02)","Target":" # the rear foot: heel and arch on one sole, the hinge at the ball\n plan = [(.82, 1.16), (1.58, 1.16), (1.72, .86), (1.74, -1.48), (.66, -1.48), (.68, .86)]\n arch = [(-1.48, .3), (-1.48, 0), (-1.1, 0), (-.9, .14), (.3, .14), (.5, 0), (1.04, 0), (1.18, .14), (1.18, .3)]\n pair(\"sole\", place_foot(two_view([(.6, 0), (1.8, 0), (1.8, .3), (.6, .3)], arch, plan)), \"joint\", *FT, bevel=.02)\n pair(\"foot_frame\", place_foot(two_view([(.76, .29), (1.64, .29), (1.58, .62), (.82, .62)],\n [(-1.44, .29), (1.08, .29), (.98, .64), (-1.38, .5)])), \"frame\", *FT, bevel=BEVEL)\n pair(\"toe_hinge\", place_foot(cylinder(.14, .76, 1.64, 10, axis=\"x\", at=(-1.56, .26))), \"joint\", *FT, smooth=True)\n toe_plan = [(.7, -1.62), (1.7, -1.62), (1.68, -2.3), (1.5, -2.58), (.9, -2.58), (.72, -2.3)]\n pair(\"toe_frame\", place_foot(two_view([(.6, .06), (1.8, .06), (1.8, .44), (.6, .44)],\n [(-1.62, .06), (-2.5, .06), (-2.6, .16), (-2.48, .3), (-1.62, .44)], toe_plan)), \"frame\", *FT,\n bevel=BEVEL)\n pair(\"toe_sole\", place_foot(two_view([(.6, 0), (1.8, 0), (1.8, .07), (.6, .07)], [(-1.62, 0), (-2.5, 0), (-2.5, .07), (-1.62, .07)],\n toe_plan)), \"joint\", *FT, bevel=.015)\n pair(\"heel_frame\", place_foot(box(.82, 1.58, .56, 1.12, .28, .62)), \"frame\", *FT, bevel=.02)"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/frame_std.py",
      "Replacement": "    # the rear foot: heel and arch on one sole, tapered to sit cleanly under pointed sabatons\n    plan = [(.9, 1.12), (1.5, 1.12), (1.56, .82), (1.52, -1.48), (.88, -1.48), (.84, .82)]\n    arch = [(-1.48, .28), (-1.48, 0), (-1.1, 0), (-.9, .14), (.3, .14), (.5, 0), (1.04, 0), (1.14, .14), (1.14, .28)]\n    pair(\"sole\", place_foot(two_view([(.82, 0), (1.58, 0), (1.58, .28), (.82, .28)], arch, plan)), \"joint\", *FT, bevel=.02)\n    pair(\"foot_frame\", place_foot(two_view([(.88, .27), (1.52, .27), (1.48, .58), (.92, .58)],\n                                     [(-1.42, .27), (1.04, .27), (.94, .6), (-1.36, .46)])), \"frame\", *FT, bevel=BEVEL)\n    pair(\"toe_hinge\", place_foot(cylinder(.12, .9, 1.5, 10, axis=\"x\", at=(-1.54, .24))), \"joint\", *FT, smooth=True)\n    toe_plan = [(.88, -1.58), (1.52, -1.58), (1.44, -2.25), (1.3, -2.72), (1.1, -2.72), (.96, -2.25)]\n    pair(\"toe_frame\", place_foot(two_view([(.86, .06), (1.54, .06), (1.54, .38), (.86, .38)],\n                                    [(-1.58, .06), (-2.65, .06), (-2.72, .14), (-2.55, .26), (-1.58, .38)], toe_plan)), \"frame\", *FT,\n         bevel=BEVEL)\n    pair(\"toe_sole\", place_foot(two_view([(.86, 0), (1.54, 0), (1.54, .07), (.86, .07)], [(-1.58, 0), (-2.65, 0), (-2.65, .07), (-1.58, .07)],\n                                   toe_plan)), \"joint\", *FT, bevel=.015)\n    pair(\"heel_frame\", place_foot(box(.9, 1.5, .56, 1.08, .26, .58)), \"frame\", *FT, bevel=.02)",
      "Target": "    # the rear foot: heel and arch on one sole, the hinge at the ball\n    plan = [(.82, 1.16), (1.58, 1.16), (1.72, .86), (1.74, -1.48), (.66, -1.48), (.68, .86)]\n    arch = [(-1.48, .3), (-1.48, 0), (-1.1, 0), (-.9, .14), (.3, .14), (.5, 0), (1.04, 0), (1.18, .14), (1.18, .3)]\n    pair(\"sole\", place_foot(two_view([(.6, 0), (1.8, 0), (1.8, .3), (.6, .3)], arch, plan)), \"joint\", *FT, bevel=.02)\n    pair(\"foot_frame\", place_foot(two_view([(.76, .29), (1.64, .29), (1.58, .62), (.82, .62)],\n                                     [(-1.44, .29), (1.08, .29), (.98, .64), (-1.38, .5)])), \"frame\", *FT, bevel=BEVEL)\n    pair(\"toe_hinge\", place_foot(cylinder(.14, .76, 1.64, 10, axis=\"x\", at=(-1.56, .26))), \"joint\", *FT, smooth=True)\n    toe_plan = [(.7, -1.62), (1.7, -1.62), (1.68, -2.3), (1.5, -2.58), (.9, -2.58), (.72, -2.3)]\n    pair(\"toe_frame\", place_foot(two_view([(.6, .06), (1.8, .06), (1.8, .44), (.6, .44)],\n                                    [(-1.62, .06), (-2.5, .06), (-2.6, .16), (-2.48, .3), (-1.62, .44)], toe_plan)), \"frame\", *FT,\n         bevel=BEVEL)\n    pair(\"toe_sole\", place_foot(two_view([(.6, 0), (1.8, 0), (1.8, .07), (.6, .07)], [(-1.62, 0), (-2.5, 0), (-2.5, .07), (-1.62, .07)],\n                                   toe_plan)), \"joint\", *FT, bevel=.015)\n    pair(\"heel_frame\", place_foot(box(.82, 1.58, .56, 1.12, .28, .62)), \"frame\", *FT, bevel=.02)"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/frame_std.py starting at line 282 (+12/-12 lines).

agent

+20:55
reasoning

Investigating board_sleek.py reveals solid primitives using hatch, accent, and bevel. Examining knightkit.py shows a solid primitive as well. This suggests a pattern of 3D solid modeling operations, likely for creating specific shapes.

  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py","Replacement":" P.solid(f\"sabaton{i}\", fit(sh.bm()), role, *FT, bevel=0)","Target":" P.solid(f\"sabaton{i}\", fit(sh.bm()), role, *FT, bevel=.01)"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py",
      "Replacement": "        P.solid(f\"sabaton{i}\", fit(sh.bm()), role, *FT, bevel=0)",
      "Target": "        P.solid(f\"sabaton{i}\", fit(sh.bm()), role, *FT, bevel=.01)"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py starting at line 367 (+1/-1 lines).
  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/lab/board_sleek.py","Replacement":" bm = s.bm()\n up = subtract(copy(bm), _below(hi))\n lo = subtract(bm, _above(hi))\n # the ivory field above the V is the hatch: it leaves with the pod, so no box is cut in the breast\n P.solid(\"hatch\", up, \"accent\", H, bevel=0)\n P.solid(\"breast_lo\", lo, \"main\", T, bevel=0)","Target":" bm = s.bm()\n up = subtract(copy(bm), _below(hi))\n lo = subtract(bm, _above(hi))\n # the ivory field above the V is the hatch: it leaves with the pod, so no box is cut in the breast\n P.solid(\"hatch\", up, \"accent\", H, bevel=.012)\n P.solid(\"breast_lo\", lo, \"main\", T, bevel=.012)"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/lab/board_sleek.py",
      "Replacement": "    bm = s.bm()\n    up = subtract(copy(bm), _below(hi))\n    lo = subtract(bm, _above(hi))\n    # the ivory field above the V is the hatch: it leaves with the pod, so no box is cut in the breast\n    P.solid(\"hatch\", up, \"accent\", H, bevel=0)\n    P.solid(\"breast_lo\", lo, \"main\", T, bevel=0)",
      "Target": "    bm = s.bm()\n    up = subtract(copy(bm), _below(hi))\n    lo = subtract(bm, _above(hi))\n    # the ivory field above the V is the hatch: it leaves with the pod, so no box is cut in the breast\n    P.solid(\"hatch\", up, \"accent\", H, bevel=.012)\n    P.solid(\"breast_lo\", lo, \"main\", T, bevel=.012)"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/lab/board_sleek.py starting at line 41 (+2/-2 lines).
  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/lab/board_plate.py","Replacement":" P.solid(\"breast\", bm, \"main\", T, bevel=0)\n P.solid(\"hatch\", hatch, \"accent\", H, bevel=0)","Target":" P.solid(\"breast\", bm, \"main\", T, bevel=.012)\n P.solid(\"hatch\", hatch, \"accent\", H, bevel=.01)"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/lab/board_plate.py",
      "Replacement": "    P.solid(\"breast\", bm, \"main\", T, bevel=0)\n    P.solid(\"hatch\", hatch, \"accent\", H, bevel=0)",
      "Target": "    P.solid(\"breast\", bm, \"main\", T, bevel=.012)\n    P.solid(\"hatch\", hatch, \"accent\", H, bevel=.01)"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/lab/board_plate.py starting at line 52 (+2/-2 lines).

agent

+21:31
reasoning

The board_sleek.py script appears to split edges before the boolean difference operation. This suggests a potential issue, as Blender's boolean difference requires closed manifold volumes. Splitting edges may be intended to create these closed volumes but the order seems incorrect. Reversing this operation sequence could resolve the boolean subtraction failure.

Splitting edges within the boolean difference operation creates non-manifold meshes. This occurs because the edge splits duplicate vertices. The boolean operations require manifold meshes, so this operation must happen after all booleans, or be handled differently. Examination of the lib.solid() function shows the potential for the edges to be split in a later processing step, making the order of operations the key issue. The use of set_sharp_from_angle may have to be altered to avoid the vertex duplication.

The set_sharp_from_angle attribute is recognized by Blender and glTF exporters when export_normals=True. Moving the edge splitting to lib.solid() after boolean operations guarantees proper hard splits. Examining kit/lib.py shows that boolean operations occur before the call to solid(). Removing split_edges from Sheet.bm() ensures manifold meshes for boolean operations. The set_sharp_from_angle operation will handle the edge splitting.

  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py","Replacement":" bmesh.ops.remove_doubles(bm, verts=bm.verts, dist=1e-6) # closes a pole\n bmesh.ops.recalc_face_normals(bm, faces=bm.faces)\n return bm","Target":" bmesh.ops.remove_doubles(bm, verts=bm.verts, dist=1e-6) # closes a pole\n bmesh.ops.recalc_face_normals(bm, faces=bm.faces)\n sharp = [e for e in bm.edges if len(e.link_faces) == 2 and e.link_faces[0].normal.angle(e.link_faces[1].normal, 0) > math.radians(12)]\n if sharp:\n bmesh.ops.split_edges(bm, edges=sharp)\n return bm"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py",
      "Replacement": "        bmesh.ops.remove_doubles(bm, verts=bm.verts, dist=1e-6)  # closes a pole\n        bmesh.ops.recalc_face_normals(bm, faces=bm.faces)\n        return bm",
      "Target": "        bmesh.ops.remove_doubles(bm, verts=bm.verts, dist=1e-6)  # closes a pole\n        bmesh.ops.recalc_face_normals(bm, faces=bm.faces)\n        sharp = [e for e in bm.edges if len(e.link_faces) == 2 and e.link_faces[0].normal.angle(e.link_faces[1].normal, 0) > math.radians(12)]\n        if sharp:\n            bmesh.ops.split_edges(bm, edges=sharp)\n        return bm"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/lab/knightkit.py starting at line 94 (+0/-3 lines).
  • edit_file{"Path":"~/work/sortie/kit/lib.py","Replacement":" me = o.data\n if smooth:\n me.shade_smooth()\n me.set_sharp_from_angle(angle=math.radians(12))","Target":" me = o.data\n if smooth:\n me.shade_smooth()\n me.set_sharp_from_angle(angle=math.radians(15))"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/sortie/kit/lib.py",
      "Replacement": "    me = o.data\n    if smooth:\n        me.shade_smooth()\n        me.set_sharp_from_angle(angle=math.radians(12))",
      "Target": "    me = o.data\n    if smooth:\n        me.shade_smooth()\n        me.set_sharp_from_angle(angle=math.radians(15))"
    }

    result, 1 line

    Made 1 replacement in ~/work/sortie/kit/lib.py starting at line 198 (+1/-1 lines).