agent

+55:22
reasoning

The prompt emphasizes the importance of carefully examining all messages, especially from the lead and owner, given the batch processing of steering messages from a parallel run, which means identical challenges and steering instructions are being received.

The owner's directive requires redesigning the character, including body modifications and custom armor, moving beyond the initial kit. The task is to create a finished, exportable 3D model (GLB or VRM), rigged if possible, for use in a camera renderer. Relevant context includes "flattice," a lattice-based technique for perspective faces, documented in existing research.

Examining the provided documents and directives, the focus is on utilizing the "flattice" technique for perspective faces within a camera renderer. The process involves copying a perspective lens script, reading the full inventory, and then creating a 3D model. The goal is to produce a model ready for the camera renderer, documented with time tracking.

The owner's messages indicate a desire for substantial deviation from the established project direction, specifically regarding character hair and body structure, advocating for a radical improvement. Initial thought was focused on providing a text-only response, but the full context of the messages must be considered before responding. The intent is to analyze this interaction as a complete set of steering messages.

The structure of the prompt suggests a benchmark session, replaying steering messages from a live run, aiming for a complete adversarial pass in one turn. The goal is to produce a deliverable including an index.html with before/after comparison, perspective camera shot, and a breakdown of deviations from the previous approach. Crucially, a "Deviation from the old route" block must be included.

The owner's directives strongly emphasize a complete overhaul of the character, requiring original design work, custom armor, and body modifications to break free from the constraints of the existing project. The instructions clearly indicate an adversarial pass necessitates departing significantly from the previous character design, with an emphasis on producing a high-quality, finished 3D model, either in GLB or VRM format. This involves using Blender to address and correct previously identified faults, moving beyond the base kit and creating a unique costume and armor.

Examining the instructions, the focus is on utilizing the "flattice" technique for perspective faces. Copying the perspective lens script and reading the inventory is the next logical step before model creation. The goal is to produce a perspective shot of the model within a camera renderer. Time tracking each step is crucial for efficient resource allocation.

  • read_file{"Path":"~/work/lowmarch/docs/map.md"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/work/lowmarch/docs/map.md"
    }

    result, 70 lines

    Showing lines 1-69 of 69
    1: # Map of the repo
    2: 
    3: What's current, what's stale, where the big files are. Checked 2026-11-08 at `c4f1015`. Nothing was moved or deleted.
    4: "Live" means the armory build or the first-session kit reaches it. Reach was read from imports, including the
    5: `__import__` calls in `outfit.py`, not from running every path.
    6: 
    7: ## Docs
    8: 
    9: | File | Status |
    10: |---|---|
    11: | `handbook.md` | **Start here** |
    12: | `map.md`, `todos-2026-11-08.md` | Current; suggestions only |
    13: | `portrait-guide.md` | Detail log, 40 lessons. True when written, some since contradicted; marks are in the handbook |
    14: | `vroid.md` | Current. Says 54 expression shapes at the top; the files carry 57 (2.14) and 56 (older). Licence: see #1443 |
    15: | `anthro.md` | Current for bodies |
    16: | `proportions.md` | Bodies current; face ratios are reported, not held, since lesson 30 |
    17: | `makehuman.md` | Current: references for the cage |
    18: | `study.md` | Current; one clause is guessed (handbook, Things that don't bend) |
    19: | `quaternius.md` | Stale: a spike that lost (lesson 21) |
    20: 
    21: ## Tools
    22: 
    23: **First-session kit (new):** `tools/session/` (`frame.py`, `rows.py`, `smoke.sh`, `smoke_spec.json`), `review/frame/index.html`.
    24: 
    25: **Render scripts (copied in 11-08 from `~/Projects/lowmarch-bench/kit`, which still has the originals):** `tools/shots/`:
    26: `arm_shoot.py` (ran 11-08), `variant_build.py`, `all14.sh`, `all14_sheet.py`, `expr_build_tiles.py`, `expr_page.html`. Only
    27: `all14.sh` changed, to find its own folder.
    28: 
    29: | Status | Files |
    30: |---|---|
    31: | Live: the armory | `cage`, `heads`, `fit`, `proportions`, `anthro`, `makehuman`, `collide`, `vroid_portrait`, `vrm`, `export_glb`, `poses`, `rig`, `fitting`; `review/vroid-02/build.py`, `sheets.py`, `index.html`; `art/cast/cast.py`, `expressions.txt` |
    32: | Live checks | `lash_check`, `lash_shots`, `checks`, `regress`, `review/vroid-02/snapshot.py` (keeps the baseline `regress` reads), `review/vroid-02/duel_check.py` (build imports `chars_for` from it), `hair_check` (standalone, nothing imports it) |
    33: | Kept for later: costumes and motion on old bases, reached from the build | `outfit`, `plates`, `gear`, `mobs`, `hair`, `clips`, `duel`, `terrain`, `saber_study` (benchmark, not for the game). Not unused: the armory's inspection shorts come from `mobs.underwear` and the hair texture from `hair` |
    34: | Spike that lost, still imported by the build | `mass`, `quaternius` |
    35: | Pixel era, abandoned; still imported | `head3d`, `pix`, `vecpix`, `study` |
    36: | Blocked | `tools/winvroid` (V.dll, #1105) |
    37: | Looks dead: nothing imports it | `features.py`, `compare.py` (study side-by-sides) |
    38: | Looks dead: old one-off tests, nothing imports them | `review/vroid-02/`: `battle_test`, `closeup_test`, `costume_test`, `fit_test`, `pose_test`, `mouths` |
    39: | Stale pages | `review/rowan-01/`, `art/portraits/rowan*`, `art/templates/`, `review/vroid-02/base_spike_notes.html`, `mh_workshop_notes.html` |
    40: 
    41: `vroid_portrait.py` is named for the abandoned pixel renderer, but the build still uses its `Portrait` class. Don't edit it
    42: lightly: it's in cage's cache key, and so are the other cache-key files listed in the handbook.
    43: 
    44: **Scripts that live outside the repo:**
    45: 
    46: - `~/Projects/lowmarch-bench/kit/`: the benchmark's kit, including `front_sheet.py`, `build_expr.sh`, `blind_sheet.py`, `terra_review.sh`.
    47: - `~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/*/scripts` and loose scripts there, such as `patch_lens_flattice.py` (a perspective lens for the painted page). Copy one in if it's needed again.
    48: 
    49: ## Big files
    50: 
    51: The repo's tracked files are small: `.git` is 5 MB. Everything below is outside git.
    52: 
    53: | Where | Size | What |
    54: |---|---|---|
    55: | `~/.local/share/lowmarch/vroid/lowmarch_bodies` | 14 GB | Built bodies and heads; holds cage's cache (`fits.json`). The bulk of everything |
    56: | `~/.local/share/lowmarch/vroid/samples_2_14` | 466 MB | The 26 VRoid samples |
    57: | `~/.local/share/lowmarch/makehuman` | 1.7 GB | MakeHuman data |
    58: | `~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials` | 1.9 GB | Sheets and shots; `combined-2026-10-31` is 1.8 GB |
    59: | `~/.local/share/lowmarch/tools` | 1.5 GB | Portable Blender 4.5, tar included. Unused since the spike |
    60: | `~/.local/share/lowmarch/winvroid` | 803 MB | VRoid driver data |
    61: | `~/.local/share/lowmarch/refs3d`, `study`, `quaternius`, `blender-base-meshes`, `refs`, `anthro` | 1.2 GB together | Study and spike data. References stay out of the repo |
    62: | `~/.local/share/lowmarch/sessions` | new | First-session folders from `rows.py` |
    63: | `~/Projects/lowmarch-bench/work` | 4.9 GB | Benchmark builds; `e` is 3 GB. Transcripts and judging keep the benchmark's record |
    64: | `review/out/` (git-ignored) | 1.1 GB | `versions` 410 MB, `vroid-02` 249, `base-spike` 206, `armory` 115, `mh-workshop` 89, `frozen` 14 |
    65: | `~/.local/opt/blender-5.2.3-linux-x64` | | Blender 5.2.3, unused by the pipeline |
    66: 
    67: If space is ever needed, the safest candidates to discuss are the Blender 4.5 tar, `review/out/versions` and
    68: `review/out/base-spike`. Nothing has been removed. Ask first, and check `~/Projects/lowmarch-bench/README.md`: the
    69: benchmark's raw material is being kept for a blog post (#1141).
  • read_file{"Path":"~/context/lowmarch.md"}

    input

    {
      "Path": "~/context/lowmarch.md"
    }

    result, 518 lines

    Showing lines 1-517 of 517
    1: # lowmarch (handoff, 2026-10-30)
    2: 
    3: Tab: personal/lowmarch. Repo: ~/Projects/lowmarch (local git, no remote; 32 commits, 2026-10-08 to 10-13; tree clean).
    4: The deepest context is the old severian-dev session 16fadb50 (10-07 to 10-13). Read `docs/portrait-guide.md` first
    5: (31 numbered lessons, each with what the owner asked and what changed).
    6: **Since 11-08, start at `docs/handbook.md` instead:** it marks each rule earned or guessed, and has the first-session kit (`tools/session/`, `review/frame/`). `docs/map.md` and
    7: `docs/todos-2026-11-08.md` hold the housekeeping.
    8: 
    9: ## What it is
    10: 
    11: The character art pipeline for Lowmarch, a tactics game. The battle scenes aim at Unicorn Overlord's style, and
    12: FE8 (GBA) portraits are kept as a second renderer. Characters are built by code, not modelled by hand:
    13: - VRoid models as bases: the CC0 bodies, plus the 26 AvatarSample faces and their hair (`docs/vroid.md`);
    14: - bodies reshaped by MakeHuman references;
    15: - costumes, plate armour and hair kits generated and fitted in code;
    16: - everything drawn by our own numpy rasterizer (`tools/vrm.py`). Deps: numpy and PIL only.
    17: 
    18: **Blender is not in the pipeline.** One spike used a portable Blender 4.5 to export Blender Studio base meshes
    19: (`docs/quaternius.md`). Blender 5.2.3 at ~/.local/opt is unused by lowmarch so far.
    20: 
    21: **The pixel renderer is abandoned (owner, 2026-10-30).** The armory's painted renderer (`review/vroid-02/index.html`)
    22: is the target. `tools/vroid_portrait.py` stays because the build uses its Portrait class, but nothing new is ported
    23: to its pixel path.
    24: 
    25: **Every camera is orthographic:**
    26: - the pixel and painted renderers project with a scale and no depth divide (`tools/vroid_portrait.py:730-734`);
    27: - every review page uses three.js `OrthographicCamera` (`review/out/*/site/index.html`).
    28: 
    29: Data lives outside the repo, in `~/.local/share/lowmarch/`: vroid, makehuman, quaternius, anthro, refs and
    30: blender-base-meshes. The FE8 refs are study only: never trace or ship them (`docs/study.md`).
    31: 
    32: ## How far it got
    33: 
    34: - **10-07:** the FE8 portrait study, which set the house style. The 96x80 portrait goes through `tools/pix.py` and
    35:   `vroid_portrait.py`.
    36: - **10-08:** the following were built:
    37:   - Aldric (frozen at viewer v9, now retired as a study) and Elaine;
    38:   - a Saber benchmark (study only, never for the game);
    39:   - the costume, outline-plate and hair kits, and common enemies;
    40:   - a two-character sword bind, and a painted renderer next to the pixel one;
    41:   - browser review pages that show the 3D model and both renders.
    42: - **10-09:** a base spike tried MakeHuman, Quaternius and Blender Studio meshes. VRoid bodies shaped by MakeHuman
    43:   won. VRoid Studio on the Windows side is driven from WSL (`tools/winvroid`).
    44: - **Armory v1 to v12.1 (10-09 to 10-13):** 14 T-posed bodies (`arm_m_*`, `arm_f_*`):
    45:   - proportions are held by code (`docs/proportions.md`), and bodies are read against NHANES and ANSUR
    46:     (`docs/anthro.md`);
    47:   - the heroic man and sexy woman lines, real hands and breast spring bones;
    48:   - v9 and v10: heads from VRoid sample faces, blended by look;
    49:   - v11: VRoid hair with spring physics;
    50:   - v12: collision spheres fitted to each body's skin;
    51:   - v12.1: a fix to the face-blend order.
    52: - **The owner's last verdicts:** bodies "look perfect" (10-12). Faces were "too sharp" at some angles. That fault was
    53:   our ratio fitter, so v10 keeps faces as VRoid built them (lesson 30).
    54: 
    55: ## How to run
    56: 
    57: These commands come from the tools' docstrings; none was re-run this session.
    58: - `python3 tools/vroid_portrait.py MODEL.vrm --yaw 35 --png out.png --scale 6` renders one portrait.
    59: - `LOWMARCH_SITE=armory python3 review/vroid-02/build.py` builds the armory page. Output goes to
    60:   `review/out/armory/site/`. The models are base64 GLBs, `{"glb": ...}` in `<name>.glb.json`.
    61: - Without `LOWMARCH_SITE`, the same command builds the cast viewer (vroid-02): Aldric, Elaine, Saber, the mobs and
    62:   the duel. Other sites: `mh-workshop`, `base-spike`.
    63: - `python3 tools/cage.py [NAME...]` builds armory bodies, and `python3 tools/heads.py BASE SAMPLE` builds one head.
    64: - `python3 tools/regress.py NAME [TAG]` diffs a build's geometry against the last published version.
    65: - `python3 tools/winvroid/winvroid.py bases|samples` drives VRoid Studio on Windows. It takes over the PC, so it needs
    66:   the owner's go.
    67: 
    68: ## Open threads
    69: 
    70: - **VRoid driver blocked:** `tools/winvroid`'s rebuilt V.dll is refused by Windows application control. The owner
    71:   must allow it before the driver works (`docs/vroid.md`, face session).
    72: - **Faces:**
    73:   - all 26 samples are young. A mature or sultry face needs VRoid's editor (the "option 2" session, done with the
    74:     owner away from the PC).
    75:   - The first try, `faces/face_sexy.vrm`, read cute and was set aside. Next time, start from preset 3 or 5.
    76: - **Not started:**
    77:   - the neck, which waits on the head work;
    78:   - a second armour pass (Aldric is retired);
    79:   - Unicorn Overlord-style battle animation, map sprites and fabric textures.
    80: - **Sortie** (severian-dev/sortie, tab of 10-28) borrows lowmarch VRoid bodies for its pilots. See memory
    81:   project_sortie_mech_game.
    82: 
    83: ## Research: the "flat lattice" Blender extension (2026-10-30)
    84: 
    85: **Short answer:**
    86: - **It exists, twice:** "Flattice" (flat + lattice) is the name of two unrelated add-ons. Both build a lattice aimed
    87:   at the camera, and a shape key on it squashes the mesh along the view axis. That is a per-object longer lens: the
    88:   near parts of the face (nose, cheeks) stop looming. The rumor is almost certainly DillonGoo's, which is made for
    89:   faces and went on sale this week.
    90: - **Not worth trying for lowmarch:** our cameras are orthographic, so there is no lens distortion to remove.
    91: - **Where it could help:** sortie's perspective close-ups. There the trick is a few lines of shader or numpy, not a
    92:   Blender add-on.
    93: 
    94: ### The two Flattices
    95: 
    96: | | Flattice: Stylized Flattener | Flattice |
    97: |---|---|---|
    98: | Author | Dillon Goo (DillonGoo Studios, who make Goo Engine) [1][2] | Merlin Perry [5] |
    99: | Where | Superhive [1], Gumroad [3], linked from the studio's add-ons page [4] | Blender Extensions platform [5], GitHub (README and licence only, no source) [6] |
    100: | Price | $2 [1][3] | free [5] |
    101: | Version | not stated [1] | 1.0.8, 2026-08-14 (first release 1.0.6, 2026-07-30) [7] |
    102: | Blender | 3.6 to 5.1 in the text, 3.6 to 5.2 in the table; Goo Engine 3.6 to 4.4 [1] | 4.2 and newer [5] |
    103: | Licence | GPL [1] | GPL-3.0-or-later [5] |
    104: | Packaging | legacy add-on zip (`goo_flattice_generator.zip`), Install from Disk, N panel "Goo Rigging Tools" [2] | extension, 19.6 KB, one 790-line `__init__.py`; read, not run (zip sha256 eafab40c...ed1458) |
    105: | Traction | Superhive: 100+ sales, published "3 days ago" (so about 10-27) [1]; Gumroad: 2 ratings, 5.0 [3] | 595 downloads, no reviews [5] |
    106: 
    107: **DillonGoo's (the face one):**
    108: - **Inputs:** a parent bone, any number of meshes, and the 3D cursor set at the chin [2].
    109: - **What it builds:**
    110:   - a vertex group weighted from the cursor down (with a Falloff setting), so the face flattens and the body below
    111:     doesn't;
    112:   - an empty that follows the active camera 1:1, and a lattice parent that tracks that empty;
    113:   - a low-resolution lattice with a shape key that flattens it to a plane [2].
    114: - **The switch:** a "Flattice" property on a bone, 0 to 1. It can be animated and library-overridden [1][2].
    115: - **The author's reason:** it "disconnects the focal length of the face from the focal length of the camera" [1][3].
    116: - **FAQ:** the flattening "mimics a higher focal length". The tool was built years ago, and "Geometry Nodes can
    117:   totally do it now" [8].
    118: 
    119: **Merlin Perry's (object level):**
    120: - **Create Flattice** fits a 2x2xN lattice to the selected objects' bounds and adds a Damped Track to the camera.
    121: - A `Flatten` shape key sets every point's local z to 0. A driver ties it to a `flatten` property on the camera,
    122:   from -10 to 10: 1 is flat, 0 is the model as built, negatives exaggerate depth [5][6].
    123: - **No falloff:** whole objects flatten. On a VRoid model only the Face mesh would flatten, so it would come apart
    124:   from the body at the neck.
    125: - **Possibly headless:** besides `bpy.ops.flattice.create`, the build path uses only the data API and context
    126:   (selected objects, `scene.camera`). Calling it from `blender -b` should work. Not tested.
    127: 
    128: ### What it is and isn't, against the known approaches
    129: 
    130: - **Is:** the focal-length cheat. It only does anything under a perspective camera, which it moves toward an
    131:   orthographic read.
    132: - **Isn't:**
    133:   - per-view shape correction (the anime nose and mouth cheat);
    134:   - squash and stretch of eyes or mouth;
    135:   - normal editing. Recomputed normals follow the squashed geometry, so shading flattens a little, but only as a
    136:     side effect.
    137: - **Lattice Magic, Camera Lattice** (Blender Studio, free extension 1.0.1, Blender 4.2+, GPL):
    138:   - a lattice in a camera's view that you sculpt shot by shot, with one shape key per frame;
    139:   - "like Liquify but on vertices" [9][10].
    140:   - For fixing individual shots, not a standing rig.
    141: - **View-angle shape keys, CamKeys** (beyonddev on Booth, ¥2,999, v3.4.5):
    142:   - drives shape keys from the camera's angle and distance; you sculpt the corrections yourself;
    143:   - also has a "Forced Perspective" per-object focal length, which is the same idea as Flattice [11].
    144:   - Of the add-ons found, this is the one aimed at the nose and mouth cheat.
    145: - **Face normals:**
    146:   - Easy Custom Normals (Fondant, Superhive, $10, or $20 with the Anime Face Proxy; GPL; Blender 4.3 and 4.4)
    147:     derives face normals from a rigged curve proxy through Geometry Nodes [12]. Older coverage called the proxy
    148:     "next up" [13]; the store page now sells it.
    149:   - Blender's own Data Transfer modifier copies custom normals from a proxy mesh [14].
    150: - **SDF face shadow maps:**
    151:   - a baked texture that the shader thresholds against the light's direction, giving a clean, controlled face
    152:     shadow [15].
    153:   - This is shader-side, mostly Unity and Unreal; a standalone baker exists on Booth [16]. It isn't a Blender
    154:     deformation.
    155: - **Grease Pencil Line Art:** lines from geometry [17]. Not relevant here: lowmarch draws its own outlines.
    156: 
    157: ### Fit for lowmarch
    158: 
    159: - **Under orthographic cameras, flattening along the view axis changes no silhouette.** Lowmarch already renders the
    160:   look Flattice is chasing. The owner's "too sharp at some angles" came from our fitter, not from perspective
    161:   (lesson 30).
    162: - **It would matter if:**
    163:   - Lowmarch's Unicorn Overlord-style battle scenes move to a perspective camera, or
    164:   - sortie's pilots appear in its perspective three.js cameras (`src/game/game.ts:168`, `src/view/cameras.ts:36`).
    165: - **In those cases the add-on itself doesn't carry over.** The effect is a scale of camera-space depth about the
    166:   head's center, weighted from the chin up. That is a few lines in a vertex shader, or in numpy before projection.
    167: - **If faces still read wrong at some angles, two ideas fit lowmarch better:**
    168:   - view-angle correctives, keyed by yaw in code, since every render knows its yaw;
    169:   - face normals taken from a fitted ellipsoid before shading.
    170: 
    171: ### Trial, run 2026-10-30 (DillonGoo's add-on, bought by the owner)
    172: 
    173: **Purchases:** the owner bought Flattice and DillonGoo's "Yin and Yang twin anime rigs". The files are in Windows
    174: Downloads (`[redacted: Windows home]\Downloads`):
    175: - `Flattice-Goo-fixed.zip`;
    176: - `_Yin_*` and `_Yang_*` zips in three builds each: EV (EEVEE) 4.3+, GE (Goo Engine) 4.3+, and GE Legacy 4.0+.
    177: 
    178: **Where things are:** scripts and results are in `~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/flattice-2026-10-30/`. Nothing was
    179: installed. The add-on was imported from a scratch copy and registered for each run only.
    180: 
    181: **The add-on's code** (legacy add-on, `bl_info` credits Cody Winchester and Crabnuts, about 300 lines):
    182: - **What it builds:**
    183:   - a 4x2x4 lattice, a fixed 1 m cube centred on the parent bone's head;
    184:   - a Flatten shape key that collapses the lattice's local Y;
    185:   - an empty that tracks the camera with a Damped Track. A Camera_Reference empty follows `scene.camera` through
    186:     context-property drivers.
    187: - **The falloff:** a `MOD-Flattice` vertex group, weight 1 above the 3D cursor's Z, fading to 0 over `falloff`
    188:   metres below it.
    189: - **The switch:** a "Flattice" property, 0 to 1, on the parent or properties bone. It drives the Flatten key.
    190: - **Bugs found by reading:**
    191:   - with no rig set it crashes: it checks `target_rig == ""` on a pointer;
    192:   - "no meshes selected" reports an error but doesn't stop;
    193:   - re-running resets the bone property, because `hasattr` can't see custom properties;
    194:   - the panel's chin-height setting is unused; the cursor's Z is what counts.
    195: 
    196: **Headless works.** Set `scene.Flattice_Props` (target rig, parent bone, falloff), select the meshes, put the cursor
    197: at the chin, then call `bpy.ops.setup.addflattice()`. On a VRoid armory body (`arm_f_sexy`):
    198: - the parent bone was `J_Bip_C_Head`;
    199: - the cursor sat at the face mesh's lowest point plus 1 cm;
    200: - the body mesh had to go in too, because VRoid's skull is in it. The falloff kept the neck and body out, as the
    201:   renders show.
    202: 
    203: **How the views were made:**
    204: - Cycles on the CPU, with one grey cel material: Workbench and EEVEE abort headless here, as there is no libEGL.
    205: - 512 px, framing 0.42 m of the head plane.
    206: - Lenses: 24, 35 and 85 mm, against an orthographic view, at yaw 0, 35 and 60.
    207: - "Shape" is the silhouette overlap with the orthographic view after matching size and position.
    208: 
    209: **Results (Yin rig, its own Flattice; clean masks of only the flattened meshes):**
    210: 
    211: | Lens | Shape at flatten 0, yaw 0 / 35 / 60 | Shape at flatten 1, yaw 0 / 35 / 60 |
    212: |---|---|---|
    213: | 24 mm | 0.91 / 0.90 / 0.89 | 0.93 / 0.90 / 0.91 |
    214: | 35 mm | 0.94 / 0.93 / 0.92 | 0.96 / 0.93 / 0.94 |
    215: | 85 mm | 0.97 / 0.96 / 0.95 | 0.98 / 0.97 / 0.98 |
    216: | orthographic | 1.00 | 0.99 to 1.00 (no change) |
    217: 
    218: **What the numbers mean:**
    219: - Flattening moves perspective silhouettes a little toward the orthographic one. Its visible effect is inside the face:
    220:   at 24 and 35 mm the nose and mouth stop bulging (see the sheets).
    221: - **The pivot is the neck, not the camera axis.** The flatten plane faces the line from the parent bone's head to the
    222:   camera. At very close range that line tilts: 21 degrees with the camera 0.32 m from the face. The flattened head then
    223:   shrinks vertically, so raw overlap at 24 mm got worse (0.89 to 0.85) and only the size-matched score improved.
    224: - **Under orthographic cameras it changes nothing:** overlap is 0.99 or better. That confirms there is no gain for
    225:   lowmarch's current renderers.
    226: - **The VRoid numbers are not usable.** The armory model is T-posed, so its arms are in frame and in the mask. Read the
    227:   VRoid sheet visually only.
    228: 
    229: **Shading is the catch, and the Yin rig shows the fix:**
    230: - Flattening the mesh flattens its normals. On Yin's head, the share of face normals pointing at the camera went from
    231:   19% to 47%, and normal-based cel shading washed out (my grey renders at flatten 1).
    232: - Yin's own materials don't shade from mesh normals. Skin, Scalera and Iris read a `vs_nrm` attribute, stored before the
    233:   Lattice by the GN group "Head Vertex Skeleton Normals":
    234:   - normals are blended toward directions from two locator empties, `Yin_Head_Pos` (factor 0.5) and `Yin_Neck_Pos`
    235:     (factor 0.95);
    236:   - the blend is weighted by the `NRM_Head` and `NRM_Neck` attributes, then blurred.
    237:   - So their designed shading survives the flatten.
    238: - That modifier is off in the viewport and on for renders.
    239: - **For lowmarch:** we already shade from stored vertex normals, so a depth squash in our renderer wouldn't touch
    240:   shading. The head-locator normal blend is worth copying anyway, for faces that read soft at every angle.
    241: 
    242: **Result:** Flattice does what it says, scripts headless, and costs nothing to keep. Lowmarch gets nothing from it while
    243: its cameras are orthographic. If a perspective camera comes (Unicorn Overlord-style battles, sortie close-ups), the
    244: recipe is a depth scale about the head with a chin falloff. Shade from normals stored before the squash.
    245: 
    246: ### Yin and Yang twin rigs (DillonGoo, bought 2026-10-30): review
    247: 
    248: The full review is in `~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/yin-yang-review-2026-10-30/` (`REVIEW.md`), done by a worker on the
    249: EEVEE builds, opened headless with autoexec off.
    250: - **Use `contact_sheet_armory.png`.** Its lowmarch rows come from the armory page's own painted renderer, head and whole
    251:   body, shot headless from a patched scratch copy of the built page (`scripts/arm_shoot.py`, `scripts/compare_sheet.py`).
    252: - The first sheet (`contact_sheet.png`) wrongly used `tools/vroid_portrait.py`, the old pixel path. It crops to a bust
    253:   and mangles armory bodies.
    254: 
    255: **Not a base.**
    256: - **Licence** ("Editorial" on Superhive; $40 to $70 tiers): personal or educational use only. No redistribution "in
    257:   original or modified form", and the Yin and Yang characters can't be used commercially
    258:   (https://superhivemarket.com/products/yin-yang-twins-anime-rig-pack, and the Gumroad listing
    259:   dillongoo.gumroad.com/l/yin-yang-anime-twins-rig-pack). A game build would redistribute them.
    260: - **Technically a poor fit:**
    261:   - the clothes are the body: Yin has no skin under the shirt and pants;
    262:   - a Rigify A-pose rig split over 3 armatures, about 1,640 bones;
    263:   - expressions are bones, not shape keys.
    264: - Reimplementing their techniques in our own code copies no asset.
    265: 
    266: **Lessons for lowmarch, ranked:**
    267: 1. **Proxy shading normals ("Vertex Skeleton Normals")** in `vs_nrm`:
    268:    - `n = normalize(P - mix(mean of the skeleton, nearest point on a short vertical edge inside the head, 0.5))`;
    269:    - blended in by a painted mask, blurred 5 times, renormalized; the neck uses a capsule (factor 0.95).
    270:    - Bake it at build time into the GLB normals (`tools/export_glb.py` / `review/vroid-02/build.py`). Then the armory
    271:      page's painted renderer (`review/vroid-02/index.html`), the pixel path and later the game all get it. Paint the
    272:      mask once on VRoid's shared face template. Led #1114.
    273:    - The contact sheet's A/B (our 4 bands and headlight on their mesh) shows the difference. Mesh normals give noisy
    274:      nose and cheek patches that move with yaw; the proxy gives clean ovals at every angle.
    275: 2. **One proxy for the whole head:** hair, brows, lashes and mouth use it too, so shade edges carry from hair into face.
    276: 3. **Two skin tones split at N.L 0.1**, with the rest authored. That is fewer bands than our 4.
    277: 4. **Authored shade:** a painted per-corner `Shadows` attribute, plus tiny nose, lip and eyelid shadow cards. Yang's nose
    278:    card flips sides with the light; for us that would be UV marks picked by the light's side.
    279: 5. **Line-only geometry:** `Eyelids` is edges only, for Line Art. For us, lid and nose lines as 3D polylines projected
    280:    per frame, like `draw_curve_mouth`.
    281: 
    282: **Proportions:**
    283: - Yin: 7.3 heads, eye line 0.58 down from the crown.
    284: - Yang: about 7.8 heads, eyes at 0.55, higher than any VRoid sample.
    285: - Ours: arm_f_slender 7.3 heads, arm_m_youth 6.5, both with eyes at 0.61.
    286: 
    287: **Not checked:**
    288: - the Goo Engine look;
    289: - the Wiggle 2 dependency;
    290: - GN input values beyond the group defaults;
    291: - (Since checked: the owner ran the shipped-shader turnaround with autoexec on. All 8 renders, both rigs at 4 yaws, are
    292:   pixel-identical to the autoexec-off ones. The 6 Python drivers don't touch the rest pose.)
    293: - Line Art draws nothing headless, so the sheet's outlines are approximate.
    294: 
    295: ### Face shading from the rigs' lessons (2026-10-30, owner's go)
    296: 
    297: Commits **Armory v13** (`121a1e4`, `face_normals`), **v13.1** (`dc3c532`) and **v13.2** (`fbffd7c`), in
    298: `tools/vroid_portrait.py` and on by default; portrait guide lessons 32 and 33.
    299: - **v13:** the face, brows, lines, mouth and skull are shaded from normals pointing away from a line inside the head.
    300:   The nose patch and the blotchy jaw are gone.
    301:   - The line sits at the head's middle (`forward=0.0`), not Yin's 13% forward: VRoid faces are flatter.
    302:   - Hair is off: the trick flattens the strands in the painted renderer.
    303: - **v13.1 (superseded):** a nose shadow and the chin's V on the neck, made by turning normals down in soft patches.
    304:   The owner saw scars: the edges followed the mesh's triangles.
    305: - **v13.2** (`fbffd7c`, `shadow_cards`): designed geometry instead, like the Yin rig's shadow cards.
    306:   - A crescent on the neck under the real jaw line, and a half-moon under the nose tip.
    307:   - New role "shadow": skin that only darkens into its shade tone (export, the painted page
    308:     `review/vroid-02/index.html`, the pixel path).
    309:   - `face_normals` gains a neck cylinder. Portrait guide lesson 34. Sheet: `shadow-cards.png`.
    310: - **v13.3:** the neck's line now comes from the skeleton (`neck_frame`: neck bone to head bone).
    311:   - The skin-slice estimate had broken the slender woman's card in the T-pose, which is why she and the youth
    312:     looked different. `neck-isolated.png` shows it with the neck held lit.
    313:   - The crescent is shallower and tapers before the jaw's angle, and cards darken only to a soft shade
    314:     (`min(lit, 0.37)`).
    315: - **v13.4 (`5e928b9`, kept by the owner 10-30, hair-strand shadows included):** the chin's shadow is cast in screen space from the jaw and hair (portrait guide
    316:   lesson 35, after Anime Shading Plus's depth-offset shadows).
    317:   - The painted renderer draws its info pass first; body skin walks toward the key across it.
    318:   - The chin card is off (`CHIN_CARD`). Sheet: `cast-shadows.png`.
    319: - **Light, not changed:** the armory's light is a camera headlight from the upper left, with a slightly blue shade
    320:   tint. `light-test.png` shows other directions and a warm tint; the owner found the shape, not the light, was the
    321:   problem.
    322: - **Fewer tones:** already true on faces after these two steps, so the shared skin shader was left alone.
    323: - **Step 3 (lid crease) dropped.** Painted into the face texture it can't get darker than about 55% (the skin
    324:   shader's clamp), and bangs hide it. Doing it as ink on VRoid's eyeline overlay is optional follow-up (led).
    325: - **Only arm_f_slender and arm_m_youth are rebuilt** (local `review/out/armory/site`). The other 12, and the
    326:   published armory page, are still v12.1.
    327:   - Every edit to `vroid_portrait.py` changes `tools/cage.py`'s cache key. A full refresh is
    328:     `python3 -I tools/cage.py`, then `LOWMARCH_SITE=armory python3 review/vroid-02/build.py`, then `sheets.py`,
    329:     then republishing (owner's go). Bodies come out byte-identical; it costs about a minute a body.
    330: - **Sheets and scripts:** `~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/face-shading-2026-10-30/`.
    331:   - `arm_shoot.py` shoots a patched copy of the built armory page headless.
    332:   - `variant_build.py` builds settings variants into a scratch site without touching the repo.
    333:   - `armsite_before_v13/` is the v12.1 site with Head and Body rows at 0/35/60/90.
    334: 
    335: **Flattice in the armory renderer** (`flattice-slender-before-after.png`, same folder): `patch_lens_flattice.py`
    336: gives a scratch copy of the built page a perspective lens per tile, perspective-aware outline depth, and Flattice as
    337: a vertex-shader squash (pivot at the head bone, along pivot to camera, chin falloff, normals untouched).
    338: - At flatten 1 every head layer lands on one plane and the depth buffer can't order them (z-fighting), so it uses
    339:   0.85 and scales the outline pass's depth step by the same amount.
    340: - **The chin is the cursor, not the pivot.** The docs put the 3D cursor on the chin, but the cursor only sets where
    341:   the squash starts (full above it, fading 5 cm below). The pivot is the parent bone. On the Yin rig: the falloff
    342:   starts at her chin (z 1.447), and the pivot is the head bone 4.7 cm above it, about 11 cm behind the face front.
    343:   Ours matches: cursor at the chin, pivot at J_Bip_C_Head, about 3 cm above it.
    344: - **Pivot moved to the chin's front (`flattice-pivot.png`):** the head keeps its size at 0 and 35 degrees, but at 60
    345:   and 90 the hair breaks up near the neck. The head-bone pivot is the stable one. A close-up head still looks a
    346:   little small, mostly because the unflattened shoulders bulge toward the lens. Options for the game camera: a pivot
    347:   partway forward, or a light squash on the shoulders too.
    348: 
    349: **Flattice parked (owner, 2026-10-30): no real value until game scenes are composed with a camera.**
    350: - The "something off" in the head-only renders is two lenses in one picture: a drawn-flat head on shoulders and arms
    351:   still in strong 24 mm perspective. Flattening the whole figure (`flattice-whole.png`) reads consistent, but it then
    352:   comes close to the lens-less armory camera, so the armory gains nothing.
    353: - **When scenes come:** the anime trick is characters flattened and backgrounds left in perspective. DillonGoo's own
    354:   copy says it can flatten "face, chest, or whole body", so start from whole-figure, per shot.
    355: - The scratch page patch (`patch_lens_flattice.py`) already does lens, whole-figure, head-only and pivot options.
    356: 
    357: ### Skin range (2026-10-30)
    358: 
    359: - **Armory republished** (same link, version 15): all 14 bodies with v13.4 face shading, plus a skin picker.
    360: - **The range** (`5a2b154`, `47dcd23`, portrait guide lesson 36):
    361:   - `cast.SKINS` has 12 people tones (porcelain to ebony) and 7 fantasy tones (drow_ash, drow_slate, ashen, orc,
    362:     orc_deep, sea, infernal). The mobs' older 7 tones are unchanged.
    363:   - `export_glb.skin_ramp` derives each tone's shade and deep shade; the painted renderer uses the ramp.
    364: - **The picker:** `?skin=<tone>` for headless sheets; `SKIN_PICKER` in build.py lists it. The armory bodies themselves
    365:   still default to light skin.
    366: - **Sheets:** `skin-range-people.png`, `skin-range-fantasy.png` (trials folder). Runner: `scripts/run_range.sh`.
    367: - **Next range candidates (owner to order):**
    368:   - hair types VRoid lacks (curly, coily, braids, locs) via our hair kit;
    369:   - feature variety (nose, lips, eye shape);
    370:   - eye colours, freckles and marks;
    371:   - fantasy ears (elf);
    372:   - ages and builds beyond the 14.
    373: 
    374: ### Expressions: Yin and Yang vs ours (2026-10-30)
    375: 
    376: Sheet: `~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/yin-yang-review-2026-10-30/expressions-vs-yin-yang.png`. It shows 9
    377: expressions and 5 lip-sync mouths, at 0 and 35 degrees, with Yin beside our slender woman and Yang beside our youth.
    378: 
    379: **How their faces are posed:** with the rig's own macro controls, Rigify Action constraints (`yy_action_map.py`):
    380: - `eye-look-blink-macro`: Z+ gives happy closed eyes, Z- sleepy closed eyes;
    381: - `lip-corner-MASTER.L/R`: Z for smile and frown;
    382: - `brow-shape-control`;
    383: - eye tilt on the `eye-blink-top/bottom` rotation;
    384: - the `jaw` rotation;
    385: - `sync-control`: 9 lip-sync mouths.
    386: 
    387: Line Art evaluates headless once its Grease Pencil objects are visible in the viewport. `yin_expr.py` projects its
    388: strokes and `expr_lines.py` draws them, because the rig's closed mouth is Line Art.
    389: 
    390: **Ours:** VRoid's 57 shapes, baked at build (`variant_build.py rest=...`).
    391: 
    392: **Findings:**
    393: - **Open mouths:** ours are a flat dark-brown blob. VRoid's own mouth texture (FaceMouth) holds white teeth, a pink
    394:   tongue and a pink lining, and the painted renderer throws it away (the mouth role is flat colour "1"). Yin shows
    395:   teeth and tongue.
    396: - **Brows:** our slender woman's bangs cover her brows, so angry and sad barely read. Yin's bangs stop above hers,
    397:   with gaps. She does not draw brows over hair; that anime trick would be our own option.
    398: - **Asymmetry:** VRoid has no one-sided mouth shapes, so no smirk. The rig's bones allow it.
    399: - **Closed-mouth shapes:** theirs are drawn strokes (a "u" smile, an inverted-v frown). Ours are VRoid's painted line,

    118 more lines not shown.

  • run_command{"CommandLine":"blender -b --version && find ~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials -maxdepth 3 -name \"*flattice*\" -o -name \"*lens*\"","WaitMsBeforeAsync":5000,"toolSummary":"Check Blender version and locate Flattice files"}

    input

    {
      "CommandLine": "blender -b --version && find ~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials -maxdepth 3 -name \"*flattice*\" -o -name \"*lens*\"",
      "WaitMsBeforeAsync": 5000,
      "toolSummary": "Check Blender version and locate Flattice files"
    }

    result, 25 lines

    Command exited with code 0.
    
    Command output:
    Blender 5.2.3 LTS (hash e13b728c6880 built 2026-10-22 01:35:05)
    Blender 5.2.3 LTS
    	build date: 2026-10-22
    	build time: 01:35:05
    	build commit date: 2026-10-21
    	build commit time: 09:21
    	build hash: e13b728c6880
    	build branch: blender-v5.2-release
    	build platform: Linux
    	build type: Release
    	build c flags:  -Wall -Werror=implicit-function-declaration -Wstrict-prototypes -Werror=return-type -Werror=vla -Wmissing-prototypes -Wno-char-subscripts -Wno-unknown-pragmas -Wpointer-arith -Wunused-parameter -Wwrite-strings -Wlogical-op -Wundef -Winit-self -Wmissing-include-dirs -Wno-div-by-zero -Wtype-limits -Wformat-signedness -Wrestrict -Wno-stringop-overread -Wno-stringop-overflow -Wnonnull -Wabsolute-value -Wuninitialized -Wredundant-decls -Wshadow -Wimplicit-fallthrough=5 -Wno-error=unused-but-set-variable  -march=x86-64-v2 -std=gnu11 -pipe -fPIC -funsigned-char -fno-strict-aliasing -ffp-contract=off  
    	build c++ flags:  -Wuninitialized -Wredundant-decls -Wall -Wno-invalid-offsetof -Wno-sign-compare -Wlogical-op -Winit-self -Wmissing-include-dirs -Wno-div-by-zero -Wtype-limits -Werror=return-type -Wno-char-subscripts -Wno-unknown-pragmas -Wpointer-arith -Wunused-parameter -Wwrite-strings -Wundef -Wcomma-subscript -Wformat-signedness -Wrestrict -Wno-suggest-override -Wuninitialized -Wno-stringop-overread -Wno-stringop-overflow -Wimplicit-fallthrough=5 -Wundef -Wmissing-declarations  -march=x86-64-v2 -pipe -fPIC -funsigned-char -fno-strict-aliasing -ffp-contract=off  
    	build link flags: 
    	build system: CMake
    ~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/flattice-2026-10-30
    ~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/flattice-2026-10-30/flattice-armory-faces.png
    ~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/flattice-2026-10-30/scripts/yin_lens.py
    ~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/face-shading-2026-10-30/flattice-pivot.png
    ~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/face-shading-2026-10-30/flattice-slender-before-after.png
    ~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/face-shading-2026-10-30/flattice-whole.png
    ~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/face-shading-2026-10-30/scripts/flattice_pairs.py
    ~/.local/share/lowmarch/trials/face-shading-2026-10-30/scripts/patch_lens_flattice.py